As I mentioned last week I came up with the idea for this pie for my brother-in-law, Kevin's birthday. I eventually ended up making 2 of these pies. One for Kevin to take home and one for me to sample. Unfortunately Kevin got the first pie, the "Test" pie as it were. The first thing I did wrong was not tempering the eggs enough before adding them to the hot filling. I tempered them, just not enough. The filling wasn't as smooth as I imagined it would be, but figured it would smooth out once it cooled.
I continued with the process and just when I was ready to pour the filling into the pie crust I noticed several crumbs on the bottom of the crust. I decided I would get them out first and tilted the pan over the sink to tap the loose crumbs out. Of course I tilted too much and the entire crust goes tumbling into my wet sink.
I began to panic, and did a quick inventory of my pantry trying to determine if I had the ingredients to make another chocolate cookie crust. I didn't. I had some Graham cracker crumbs and could make a Graham cracker crust, but that just wouldn't work. I came to the conclusion that I was going to have to go out and either buy a new crust or the ingredients to make my own.
During this entire time by the way, my pie filling is still sitting in a very warm saucepan, continuing to cook. Once I realized that fact, I poured the hot filling into a bowl and stuck in the refrigerator. I ran to the nearest store as quickly as I could, which isn't that quick since I live in a "new-ish" development on the outskirts of town.
I returned home ready to finish preparing the pie. I pulled the filling out of the refrigerator and went to pour it into my newly purchased chocolate cookie crust. Nothing happened. The pudding/custard like filling had firmed rather swiftly while I was away, thanks to my under-tempering the eggs, and had conformed to the shape of the bowl. I used a spatula to release it from the bowl and it landed in the center of the crust, making a nice "plopping" sound. I spread it out in the crust, still concerned about the texture but being that it was now 11:30 at night, there wasn't much more I could do.
I brought Keving the pie and he took it home. I have assumed the worst and imagine the filling was a gelatinous glob that couldn't have been too good. I'm sure it tasted fine, but the texture was just unappealing.
A few days later I made a second pie, for myself to try out. I made sure I had 2 extra crusts, just in case and that my eggs were well tempered. The filling turned out silky smooth and the pie was amazing. My husband said it was like a dessert you would find at Disney World, the highest compliment he can give! Someday when the spirits of Harpo Marx and Lucy Ricardo aren't inhabiting my body, I hope to make Kevin another pie. As a spoon goes flying out of my hand and hits me in the forehead, the bottom of the salt shaker pops out right over tonight's dinner and I slip in puddle of water I spilled a few minutes ago, I realize it might be a little while.
Tips:
- Make your own caramel sauce or use store bought. After all my troubles I used Harry and David's Caramel Cream Sauce. It was perfection (thanks Kim!)
- I bought my espresso powder at William's Sonoma, though other stores carry it as well.
- Don't let the long list of ingredients and multitude of directions fool you. This pie is easy to make (if you're not me on a bad night) and only takes about 20-30 minutes of actual work, the rest of the time it's chilling in the refrigerator.
- Temper your eggs thoroughly!
- Anything less than whole milk won't work. The pudding just won't set up firm enough.
Mocha Caramel Toffee Pie
1 chocolate cookie crust

1/4 cup cornstarch
3/4 cup sugar
2 tablespoon espresso powder
2 tablespoon cocoa powder
1/4 teaspoon salt
2 3/4 cups whole milk or half and half
4 egg yolks
1 oz semi-sweet chocolate, melted
1/4 cup Kahlua
1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract
4 tablespoons butter, softened
3/4 cup
caramel sauce (click link for recipe or use store bought)
1 recipe for Toffee Whipped Cream, recipe below
Pie Filling:
In a medium saucepan stir together cornstarch, sugar, espresso powder, cocoa powder and salt. Whisk in milk and cook over medium-high heat. Once mixture begins to boil and thicken, remove from heat. In a small bowl, lightly beat egg yolks and temper by slowly adding 4 tablespoons of hot mixture 1 tablespoon at a time, whisking continuously. Whisk egg mixture into saucepan and return to heat. Bring to a boil and continue cooking for 2 minutes. Remove from heat Slowly pour melted chocolate, Kahlua and vanilla into saucepan. Stirring to combine. Add butter, 1 tablespoon at a time, allowing each tablespoon to melt before adding the next. Allow mixture to cool for 3-5 minutes and pour into prepared crust. Cover tightly with plastic wrap and refrigerate for 3 hours or until set. Once filling is set, pour
caramel sauce over top of pie and spread to edges (it's easier to spread if
slightly warm). Return to refrigerator for 2-3 hours to let caramel firm up. Top with Toffee Whipped Cream and serve chilled.
Toffee Whipped Cream
1 1/4 cup heavy cream
1/4 cup marshmallow cream, optional
1/4 cup sugar
1 teaspoon vanilla
1/2 cup toffee pieces
In a large, chilled mixing bowl beat/whip the cream until thick and peaks stand on their own. Beat in marshmallow cream, sugar and vanilla (add more sugar if desired). Once combined, gently fold in toffee pieces.