Friday, May 21, 2010

PieDay Friday-Frosting Pie

I had long forgotten about this pie until just recently.The other day, I was cleaning out the hard drive on our old PC and saw a document I had labeled "Frosting Pie". It didn't ring any bells, even after looking at the ingredient list but I was curious enough to make it. After one bite it all came back to me.

When my husband and I were first married and living at his parent's house, his mother would often blend sour cream and cake frosting (from a container) together and spread it on Graham crackers as a snack. I thought it was so strange and a bit gross until I actually tried it and found that it was similar in flavor to a cheesecake!
One night my mother-in-law was craving that particular snack but was out of Graham crackers. Eager to be the helpful daughter she never had, I rumaged in the pantry and found a Graham cracker pie crust. I told her that I would make her a pie that resembled her beloved snack food and set to work. The pie turned out great and she told me I should type up the recipe so I would remember it, which I of course did. Not long afterwards, my husband and I moved into our own house and the memory of the mere existence of the pie was stored in some deep, recessed part of my brain.  Today, I bring back the pie that brought such a smile to my MIL and hope it does the same for you!

  • I used Betty Crocker Whipped Buttercream frosting for my pie, but any flavor will work.
  • The crushed Oreos I used really complimented the over-all flavor of the pie and I would definetly recommend them!
  • For a fluffier pie, add 1 container of thawed Cool Whip or 1 1/2 cups of freshly whipped cream. You may be able to get 2 pies out of the recipe if you do this.

Frosting Pie

1 12oz container of frosting, any flavor
1 12oz container sour cream
1 14oz can sweetened condensed milk
1 chocolate or graham cracker pie crust
1/2 cup crushed cookies for garnish

In a large mixing bowl, beat together the sour cream and sweetened condensed milk. Beat in the frosting until well blended. Pour mixture into prepared crust and sprinkle crumbled cookies on top. Refrigerate at least 3 hours before serving.


Le Chateau des fleurs said...

This is a very easy recipe and it looks Yummy. Cute blog!
Happy Friday Follow!
Following your blog, come see mine and follow me back.
Gros bisous

Denise said...

Stopping by from Trendy Treehouse's Follow Me Friday to say Hi!

Stop by. I have several giveaways:
List PlanIt

Tausha said...

I am coming over from NFF-This recipe got me at frosting and sweetened condensed milk! I AM SO MAKING THIS!!!!
I am going to peak around a little more and see what other fabulous recipes I MUST make!
So glad to meet you!!
Happy Weekend!!

Carol said...

Ooooh! A recipe blog...I love it!
I'm your new follower & hope you can come follow me! Have a great weekend!

Brianna! said...

the recipe sounds pretty simple:)


p.s. Im a new follower

Sarah @ The Pumpkin Patch said...

Hello! I saw you on Favorite Things Friday. I am a "pumpkin" blog too, so I had to come visit. I love all of your recipes. I host a Messy Monday and a Transform Tuesday linky party. I love for you to join either or both.

Take care.

Jerri said...

With a name like "frosting pie" this HAS to be good! And it definitely looks yummy! Thanks for linking up Friday Favorites!

Sinful Southern Sweets said...

Oh my! How could you possibly go wrong with a dessert named "Frosting Pie" ? Love it!
Happy Friday Following!

Post a Comment

Related Posts with Thumbnails